Cost prevents operators from going green

Dorking, Surrey, UK: The high capital cost of greener vehicles and technology and the lack of viable alternative fuel vehicles are the two biggest barriers that road transport companies face in reducing environmental impact, according to a survey by Paragon Software Systems.

Paragon, which provides routing and scheduling systems, surveyed UK operators on green initiatives. Three quarters of respondents reported increasing pressure on their logistics operations to reduce environmental impact in the last 12 months.

And most (66%) believe that much more needs to be done to keep pace with public pressure for action. The findings suggest that the greatest pressure for change is financial, with 56% of respondents highlighting added costs such as rising fuel prices.

The need to comply with central government (36%) or local government (26%) regulation was very much a secondary driver, followed by the need to meet customer (22%) and internal (18%) corporate social responsibility requirements.

The results also point towards the importance of public and staff opinion, with 25% and 16% of respondents respectively claiming that significant pressure was coming from their growing dissatisfaction, Paragon says.
Almost half (46%) of respondents claimed that substantial green improvements had been achieved by their logistics operation in the past year, a far greater proportion than the 21% that said no positive results had been achieved. Where improvements had occurred, the vast majority was associated with reduced mileage and fuel usage as a result of enhancements to route planning and/or driver behaviour.

However, 33% simply did not know because performance data was either not available or had not been shared, pointing towards the need for greater levels of visibility, measurement and reporting within logistics operations.  
Unsurprisingly, sustainability initiatives over the past year have been largely centred around the procurement of less polluting vehicles.

Alternative fuel vehicles have yet to gain real momentum with only 18% of respondents adding them to their fleets, compared to 65% investing in Euro 6 diesel vehicles and 29% in aerodynamic or double deck trailers.

This seems to be due to the high capital cost of greener vehicles and technology as well as the lack of viable alternative fuel vehicles, with 71% and 50% stating these were major barriers to reducing environmental impact. However, 37% did say that alternative fuel trials had been undertaken in 2019, so there is a growing appetite to explore emerging vehicle technology, Paragon says.

Improving fleet efficiency was also a key focus for many with 59% of respondents reviewing their logistics operations to identify areas of improvement and 56% introducing some sort of driver behaviour monitoring, engagement and training programme. Waste management has also become an important consideration amongst logistics operations with 43% increasing recycling and a quarter taking steps to reduce delivery packaging.

When asked what is likely to be most successful in reducing the environmental impact of the road transport sector in the next five years electric HGVs (69%) and electric / alternative fuel vans (55%) were by far the most popular responses.

In addition, a significant number of respondents believed improved supply chain modelling (38%) had an important role to play as well as the introduction of urban bans for diesel vehicles (36%) and consolidation centres (19%). However, it is worth bearing in mind that 69% felt that only with new legislation will meaningful change be achieved and ensure the industry meet targets moving forward.

William Salter, managing director, Paragon Software Systems said: “The widespread frustration with politicians and big businesses, culminating in protests worldwide during 2019, should act as a wake-up call to climate-polluting industries such as the road transport sector.

“Despite advances in more efficient vehicle technology, emissions emitted by HGVs and vans continue to rise, so much more needs to be done. The findings of our annual survey suggest that most logistics operations are in some way looking to operate efficiently, but this is perhaps more linked to cost reduction than part of a genuine strategy to minimise environmental impact.”

Logistics operations are complex. Paragons latest eBook explains how operators can master logistics complexity to reduce costs and improve customer service levels. To download see:


Seton Hall University Q&A on Covid-19 and the supply chain

South Orange, New Jersey, USA: As the world attempts to navigate the uncertain conditions surrounding Covid-19, businesses, medical professionals and government officials have all struggled …


Sixfold provide real-time visibility to logistics providers in Central and Eastern Europe

Düsseldorf, Germany: Sixfold has expanded its operations to cover the Benelux, German and East European markets out of Poland. Following the release of its map …


Bolloré Logistics mobilises for pharmaceuticals transport

Paris, France: Bolloré Logistics is mobilising to support the supply of pharmaceutical products and facemasks. A health crisis unit has been created made up of …


EU help needed to resolve Turkish border delays

Geneva, Switzerland: The IRU has called on the European Commission to intervene in the treatment of truck drivers at Turkish borders. Turkey is not allowing …



  • Engage Conference
    Talent in Logistics Engage Conference takes place on 21 April at Cranfield, UK

Latest Tweets

Coronavirus: Another folly in the making:

© 2020 Global Cold Chain News | Terms of use | Privacy Policy
Commercial Transport Publishing Limited, registered in England and Wales, Company No: 6453302. Registered Office: 6 Corunna Court, Corunna Road, Warwick CV34 5HQ